Category Archives: Iraq Atrocities

Torture: Wrong Yesterday, Wrong Today, Wrong Tomorrow

In nothing new under the sun, the Curmudgeonly Clerk notes accurately that many prior administrations have done quite horrible things in wartime. He notes the firebombing of Dresden and Tokyo, and the Japanese internments as examples of FDR's wartime moral failings. To which one might of course add the general conduct of the anti-insurgency campaigns in the Philippines after the Spanish-American War, the bombing of Cambodia, most of the century-long campaign against Native American tribes, just to name a few.

From this basis, he concludes I was wrong to approvingly quote Kevin Drum saying that “Under this administration, we seem to have lost the simple level of moral clarity that allowed our predecessors to tell right from wrong.”

Continue reading

Posted in Guantanamo, Iraq Atrocities, Law: Constitutional Law | 8 Comments

Basic Evil

While we lawyers get all het up about how people with a JD and a basic knowledge of the Constitution could sign a torturer's charter, and whether this is a banal evil or virulent evil, or both, Kevin Drum has his eye on the basics:

But put aside the technical analysis and ask yourself: Why has torture been such a hot topic since 9/11? The United States has fought many wars over the past half century, and in each of them our causes were just as important as today's, information from prisoners would have been just as helpful, and we were every bit as determined to win as we are now. But we still didn't authorize torture of prisoners. FDR, Truman, Eisenhower, LBJ, Reagan — all of them knew it wasn't right, and the rest of us knew it as well.

So what's different this time? Only one thing: the name of the man in the White House. Under this administration, we seem to have lost the simple level of moral clarity that allowed our predecessors to tell right from wrong. It's time to reclaim it.

And just imagine what those guys will do if they don't have to worry about re-election.

Posted in Guantanamo, Iraq Atrocities, Law: Constitutional Law | 7 Comments

Iraq Abuse Recap

Whiskey Bar: Chapter and Verse provides a compact summary of what we suspect we know about the Iraq abuse story, and the far far murkier coverup.

Posted in Iraq Atrocities | Comments Off on Iraq Abuse Recap

Fafblog Interviews Donald Rumsfeld

It's interview week over at Fafblog. Today it's Fafblog interviews Donald Rumsfeld, and Fafblog asks the questions no one asks and gets the answers no one says:

DR: Now, I've accepted responsibility before and I'll accept responsibility again for everything done under my command. But I'll be damned… damned… if I let a few systemic, widespread, and grotesque atrocities reflect on the character and conviction of the high-ranking civilian and military brass who created the environment that fostered those atrocities.

Posted in Iraq Atrocities | Comments Off on Fafblog Interviews Donald Rumsfeld

Lack of Training? Or Surplus of It?

Talkleft describes an atrocity:

TalkLeft: Teaching Prisoner Abuse A US soldier “sustained a traumatic brain injury that left him with a seizure disorder. Military records confirm that his injury “was due to soldier playing role as a detainee who was uncooperative.”

TalkLeft asks the obvious — but very serious — question:

A “training” exercise implies teaching and supervision. Who supervised the senseless beating of a soldier? And what, exactly, was being taught?

Just a few bad apples? If only.

Posted in Iraq Atrocities | Comments Off on Lack of Training? Or Surplus of It?

Give the Good Guys a Medal–Create One if Necessary

Only a Few Spoke Up on Abuse as Many Soldiers Stayed Silent—the New York Times reports on Joseph Darby and the small number of other soldiers with the decency and the guts to report abuses.

As we know, neither the right-wing media nor his neighbors have been especially kind to Spec. Darby, the soldier who made one of the important early reports.

One way to begin to restore some of my confidence in the system would be to give Spec. Darby and the other early complainants a medal or two. If there isn't an appropriate medal in the military arsenal, then it is time to create one.

It would be the right thing to do.

Posted in Iraq Atrocities | 2 Comments